Higher order receieve anybody
Tue Feb 24 10:22:08 CET 2004
From: "Ulf Wiger" <>
> Handling system messages is the one area where I've found it
> necessary to raise the abstraction level above what 'receive'
> provides. There are workarounds -- they are called gen_server
> and gen_fsm, but they have the unfortunate side-effect of
> imposing an un-erlangish message reception paradigm on the
> unsuspecting user.
I agree fully.
> I would like to see the possibility to divide messages into
> two separate categories: administrative (such as suspend,
> resume, inspect, upgrade) and operative (whatever the program
> is _really_ supposed to do. And I would like to be able to keep
> them separated without messing up the programming semantics.
I could even imagine such a separation hard-wired into the language (i.e. the
normal receive would work like Ulf's extended receive). Yes, there would be a
change in semantics, but almost no one would notice it because normal uses are
not affected. Handling system messages would be done behind the scenes by a
default handler, but this should be customizable.
Then the next generation of gen_server and friends will look a lot more like
regular processes! :-)
More information about the erlang-questions