[eeps] Commit: r44 - eeps/trunk

Robert Virding <>
Thu Aug 28 11:41:20 CEST 2008


Sorry for not commenting this earlier, but I was waiting for someone to come
with the question of what we thought about an EEP. Which has now come for
EEPs 10 and 11, sort of.

I have no real objections to EEP 10 about unicode in erlang, someone with
more unicode experience should comment it.

With EEP 11 on regular expressions, however, I have a lot of objections at
many levels and definitely feel it should *not* be accepted as it stands.
Just now I do not have the time to write down these comments, but I will do
so tonight.

I just wanted to say no no no to EEP 11.

Robert

2008/8/28 < <raimo%>>

> Author: raimo
> Date: 2008-08-28 10:50:16 +0200 (Thu, 28 Aug 2008)
> New Revision: 44
>
> Modified:
>   eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt
> Log:
> EEP 4 and 6 -> Final. EEP 10 and 11 -> Accepted.
>
> Added a comment for when implementation has been released in OTP.
>
> EEP 10 and 11 goes to Accepted by silence since there has
> been no objections nor counter-proposals for a while
> and the implementation is on its way. If anyone think
> they should be reverted to Draft, make yourself heard.
>
>
> Modified: eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt
> ===================================================================
> --- eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt     2008-08-27 10:15:53 UTC (rev 43)
> +++ eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt     2008-08-28 08:50:16 UTC (rev 44)
> @@ -18,44 +18,47 @@
>
>  Numerical Index
>
> -     num  title                                          owner
> -     ---  -----                                          -----
> +           num  title                                          owner
> +           ---  -----                                          -----
>
> - P     0  Index of Erlang Enhancement Proposals (EEPs)   Raimo Niskanen
> - P     1  EEP Purpose and Guidelines                     Per Gustafsson,
> Raimo Niskanen
> - P     2  Sample Plaintext EEP Template                  Per Gustafsson
> - P     3  Sample reStructuredText EEP Template           Per Gustafsson
> + P           0  Index of Erlang Enhancement Proposals (EEPs)   Raimo
> Niskanen
> + P           1  EEP Purpose and Guidelines                     Per
> Gustafsson, Raimo Niskanen
> + P           2  Sample Plaintext EEP Template                  Per
> Gustafsson
> + P           3  Sample reStructuredText EEP Template           Per
> Gustafsson
>
> - SA    4  New BIFs for bit-level binaries (bit strings)  Per Gustafsson
> - S     5  More Versatile Encapsulation with export_to    Per Gustafsson
> - SA    6  New BIFs for tuple and binary sizes            Bjorn Gustavsson
> - S     7  Foreign Function Interface (FFI)               Alceste Scalas
> - S     8  Types and function specifications              Kostis Sagonas
> - S     9  Library for working with binaries              Fredrik Svahn
> - S    10  Representing Unicode characters in Erlang      Patrik Nyblom
> - S    11  Built in regular expressions in Erlang         Patrik Nyblom
> - S    12  Extensions to comprehensions                   Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    13  -enum declarations                             Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    14  Guard clarification and extension              Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    15  Portable funs                                  Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    16  is_between/3                                   Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    17  Fix andalso and orelse                         Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    18  JSON bifs                                      Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    19  Comprehension multigenerators                  Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    20  Split the atoms!                               Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    21  Optional trailing commas for lists and tuples  Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> - S    22  Range checking for binaries                    Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + SF/R12B-0   4  New BIFs for bit-level binaries (bit strings)  Per
> Gustafsson
> + S           5  More Versatile Encapsulation with export_to    Per
> Gustafsson
> + SF/R12B-0   6  New BIFs for tuple and binary sizes            Bjorn
> Gustavsson
> + S           7  Foreign Function Interface (FFI)               Alceste
> Scalas
> + S           8  Types and function specifications              Kostis
> Sagonas
> + S           9  Library for working with binaries              Fredrik
> Svahn
> + SA         10  Representing Unicode characters in Erlang      Patrik
> Nyblom
> + SA/R12B-3u 11  Built in regular expressions in Erlang         Patrik
> Nyblom
> + S          12  Extensions to comprehensions                   Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          13  -enum declarations                             Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          14  Guard clarification and extension              Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          15  Portable funs                                  Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          16  is_between/3                                   Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          17  Fix andalso and orelse                         Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          18  JSON bifs                                      Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          19  Comprehension multigenerators                  Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          20  Split the atoms!                               Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          21  Optional trailing commas for lists and tuples  Richard A.
> O'Keefe
> + S          22  Range checking for binaries                    Richard A.
> O'Keefe
>
>  Key
>
> -    S - Standards Track EEP
> -    P - Process EEP
> +    S        - Standards Track EEP
> +    P        - Process EEP
>
> -    A - Accepted proposal
> -    R - Rejected proposal
> -    W - Withdrawn proposal
> -    D - Deferred proposal
> -    F - Final proposal
> +    A        - Accepted proposal
> +    R        - Rejected proposal
> +    W        - Withdrawn proposal
> +    D        - Deferred proposal
> +    F        - Final proposal
> +    /R12B-0  - Proposal is implemented in OTP release R12B-0
> +    /R12B-3u - Proposal is implemented in OTP release R12B-3,
> +               except for Unicode support according to EEP 10
>
>  Owners
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> eeps mailing list
> 
> http://www.erlang.org/mailman/listinfo/eeps
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://erlang.org/pipermail/eeps/attachments/20080828/7b6f94e5/attachment.html>


More information about the eeps mailing list