<div dir="ltr">Sorry for not commenting this earlier, but I was waiting for someone to come with the question of what we thought about an EEP. Which has now come for EEPs 10 and 11, sort of.<br><br>I have no real objections to EEP 10 about unicode in erlang, someone with more unicode experience should comment it.<br>
<br>With EEP 11 on regular expressions, however, I have a lot of objections at many levels and definitely feel it should *not* be accepted as it stands. Just now I do not have the time to write down these comments, but I will do so tonight.<br>
<br>I just wanted to say no no no to EEP 11.<br><br>Robert<br><br><div class="gmail_quote">2008/8/28 <span dir="ltr"><<a href="mailto:raimo%2Beeps@erix.ericsson.se">raimo+eeps@erix.ericsson.se</a>></span><br><blockquote class="gmail_quote" style="border-left: 1px solid rgb(204, 204, 204); margin: 0pt 0pt 0pt 0.8ex; padding-left: 1ex;">
Author: raimo<br>
Date: 2008-08-28 10:50:16 +0200 (Thu, 28 Aug 2008)<br>
New Revision: 44<br>
<br>
Modified:<br>
eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt<br>
Log:<br>
EEP 4 and 6 -> Final. EEP 10 and 11 -> Accepted.<br>
<br>
Added a comment for when implementation has been released in OTP.<br>
<br>
EEP 10 and 11 goes to Accepted by silence since there has<br>
been no objections nor counter-proposals for a while<br>
and the implementation is on its way. If anyone think<br>
they should be reverted to Draft, make yourself heard.<br>
<br>
<br>
Modified: eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt<br>
===================================================================<br>
--- eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt 2008-08-27 10:15:53 UTC (rev 43)<br>
+++ eeps/trunk/eep-0000.txt 2008-08-28 08:50:16 UTC (rev 44)<br>
@@ -18,44 +18,47 @@<br>
<br>
Numerical Index<br>
<br>
- num title owner<br>
- --- ----- -----<br>
+ num title owner<br>
+ --- ----- -----<br>
<br>
- P 0 Index of Erlang Enhancement Proposals (EEPs) Raimo Niskanen<br>
- P 1 EEP Purpose and Guidelines Per Gustafsson, Raimo Niskanen<br>
- P 2 Sample Plaintext EEP Template Per Gustafsson<br>
- P 3 Sample reStructuredText EEP Template Per Gustafsson<br>
+ P 0 Index of Erlang Enhancement Proposals (EEPs) Raimo Niskanen<br>
+ P 1 EEP Purpose and Guidelines Per Gustafsson, Raimo Niskanen<br>
+ P 2 Sample Plaintext EEP Template Per Gustafsson<br>
+ P 3 Sample reStructuredText EEP Template Per Gustafsson<br>
<br>
- SA 4 New BIFs for bit-level binaries (bit strings) Per Gustafsson<br>
- S 5 More Versatile Encapsulation with export_to Per Gustafsson<br>
- SA 6 New BIFs for tuple and binary sizes Bjorn Gustavsson<br>
- S 7 Foreign Function Interface (FFI) Alceste Scalas<br>
- S 8 Types and function specifications Kostis Sagonas<br>
- S 9 Library for working with binaries Fredrik Svahn<br>
- S 10 Representing Unicode characters in Erlang Patrik Nyblom<br>
- S 11 Built in regular expressions in Erlang Patrik Nyblom<br>
- S 12 Extensions to comprehensions Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 13 -enum declarations Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 14 Guard clarification and extension Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 15 Portable funs Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 16 is_between/3 Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 17 Fix andalso and orelse Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 18 JSON bifs Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 19 Comprehension multigenerators Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 20 Split the atoms! Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 21 Optional trailing commas for lists and tuples Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
- S 22 Range checking for binaries Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ SF/R12B-0 4 New BIFs for bit-level binaries (bit strings) Per Gustafsson<br>
+ S 5 More Versatile Encapsulation with export_to Per Gustafsson<br>
+ SF/R12B-0 6 New BIFs for tuple and binary sizes Bjorn Gustavsson<br>
+ S 7 Foreign Function Interface (FFI) Alceste Scalas<br>
+ S 8 Types and function specifications Kostis Sagonas<br>
+ S 9 Library for working with binaries Fredrik Svahn<br>
+ SA 10 Representing Unicode characters in Erlang Patrik Nyblom<br>
+ SA/R12B-3u 11 Built in regular expressions in Erlang Patrik Nyblom<br>
+ S 12 Extensions to comprehensions Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 13 -enum declarations Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 14 Guard clarification and extension Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 15 Portable funs Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 16 is_between/3 Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 17 Fix andalso and orelse Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 18 JSON bifs Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 19 Comprehension multigenerators Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 20 Split the atoms! Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 21 Optional trailing commas for lists and tuples Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
+ S 22 Range checking for binaries Richard A. O'Keefe<br>
<br>
Key<br>
<br>
- S - Standards Track EEP<br>
- P - Process EEP<br>
+ S - Standards Track EEP<br>
+ P - Process EEP<br>
<br>
- A - Accepted proposal<br>
- R - Rejected proposal<br>
- W - Withdrawn proposal<br>
- D - Deferred proposal<br>
- F - Final proposal<br>
+ A - Accepted proposal<br>
+ R - Rejected proposal<br>
+ W - Withdrawn proposal<br>
+ D - Deferred proposal<br>
+ F - Final proposal<br>
+ /R12B-0 - Proposal is implemented in OTP release R12B-0<br>
+ /R12B-3u - Proposal is implemented in OTP release R12B-3,<br>
+ except for Unicode support according to EEP 10<br>
<br>
Owners<br>
<br>
<br>
_______________________________________________<br>
eeps mailing list<br>
<a href="mailto:eeps@erlang.org">eeps@erlang.org</a><br>
<a href="http://www.erlang.org/mailman/listinfo/eeps" target="_blank">http://www.erlang.org/mailman/listinfo/eeps</a><br>
</blockquote></div><br></div>