[erlang-questions] My frustration with Erlang

Kevin Scaldeferri <>
Sun Sep 14 00:07:39 CEST 2008


On Sep 13, 2008, at 1:56 PM, Edwin Fine wrote:

> You'd probably have to partition the load to round-robin across the  
> individual VMs, possibly using some front-end load-balancing  
> hardware. This is why I keep harping on this: some time ago I put  
> the system I am working on under heavy load to test the maximum  
> possible throughput. There was no appreciable disk I/O. The kicker  
> is that I did not see an even distribution of load across the 4  
> cores of my box. In fact, it looked as if one or maybe two cores  
> were being used at 100% and the rest were idle. When I re-ran the  
> test on a whim, using only 1 non-SMP (+S 1) node, I actually got  
> better performance.
>
> This seemed counter-intuitive and against the "Erlang SMP scales  
> linearly for CPU-intensive loads" idea. I have not done a lot of  
> investigation into this because I have other fish to fry right now,  
> but the folks over at LShift (RabbitMQ) - assuming I did not  
> misunderstand them - wrote that they had seen similar behavior when  
> running clustered Rabbit nodes (i.e. better performance from N  
> single-CPU nodes than N +S N nodes). However, they, like me, are not  
> ready to come out and state this bluntly as a fact because (I  
> believe) they feel not enough investigation has been done to make  
> this a conclusive case.

I've also been seeing similar behavior trying to parallelize the  
alioth shootout code, fwiw.  I'd also say it's premature to draw any  
concrete conclusions, but another anecdotal point.

(Also, on the particular OS & hardware the benchmarks run on, the  
total CPU usage nearly doubles for the parallel implementations.  On  
my 2-core mac, though, I see no more than a 10% increase in total CPU  
usage, and a near 100% improvement in the wall-time, as one should  
expect on the embarrassingly parallel problems.  Dunno, if this is  
related to the OS, the chip (Core 2 Duo vs Core 2 Quad), HiPE, or what.)


-kevin



More information about the erlang-questions mailing list